Joost Merloo - Rape of the mind (1)
.pdfThe Rape of the Mind
A. M. Meerloo, M.D.
The Rape of the Mind explores the Psychology of Thought Control, Menticide, and Brainwashing. Published in 1956 and written by Joost A. M. Meerloo, M.D., Instructor in Psychiatry, Columbia University Lecturer in Social Psychology, New School for Social Research, Former Chief, Psychological Department, Netherlands Forces.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PART ONE
The Techniques of Individual Submission |
6 |
CHAPTER ONE – YOU TOO WOULD CONFESS |
7 |
The Enforced Confession |
7 |
Mental Coercion and Enemy Occupation |
10 |
Witchcraft and Torture |
12 |
The Refinement of the Rack |
14 |
Menticide in Korea |
17 |
CHAPTER TWO – PAVLOV’S STUDENTS AS CIRCUS TAMERS |
21 |
The Salivating Dog |
21 |
The Conditioning of Man |
24 |
Isolation and Other Factors in Conditioning |
26 |
Mass Conditioning Through Speech |
28 |
Political Conditioning |
30 |
The Urge to be Conditioned |
33 |
CHAPTER THREE – MEDICATION INTO SUBMISSION |
35 |
The Search for Ecstasy Through Drugs |
36 |
Hypnotism and Mental Coercion |
38 |
Needling for the Truth |
41 |
The Lie-Detector |
44 |
The Therapist as an Instrument of Coercion |
45 |
CHAPTER FOUR – WHY DO THEY YIELD? |
|
THE PSYCHODYNAMICS OF FALSE CONFESSION |
47 |
The Upset Philosopher |
47 |
The Barbed-Wire Disease |
49 |
The Moment of Sudden Surrender |
50 |
The Need to Collapse |
51 |
The Need for Companionship |
53 |
Blackmailing Through Overburdening Guilt Feelings |
55 |
The Law of Survival versus the Law of Loyalty |
58 |
The Mysterious Masochistic Pact |
61 |
A Survey of Psychological Processes involved in |
|
Brainwashing and Menticide |
63 |
2
PART TWO
The Techniques of Mass Submission |
65 |
CHAPTER FIVE – THE COLD WAR AGAINST THE MIND |
65 |
The Public-Opinion Engineers |
67 |
Psychological Warfare as a Weapon of Terror |
69 |
The Indoctrination Barrage |
71 |
The Enigma of Co-existence |
72 |
CHAPTER SIX – TOTALITARIA AND ITS DICTATORSHIP |
73 |
The Robotization of Man |
74 |
Cultural Predilection for Totalitarianism |
76 |
The Totalitarian Leader |
79 |
The Final Surrender of the Robot Man |
82 |
The Common Retreat from Reality |
84 |
The Retreat to Automatization |
86 |
The Womb State |
88 |
CHAPTER SEVEN – THE INTRUSION BY TOTALITARIAN THINKING |
91 |
The Strategy of Terror |
92 |
The Purging Rituals |
94 |
Wild Accusation and Black Magic |
96 |
Spy Mania |
98 |
The Strategy of Criminalization |
99 |
Verbocracy and Semantic Fog – Talking People into Submission |
101 |
Logocide |
103 |
Labelomania |
104 |
The Apostatic Crime in Totalitaria |
105 |
CHAPTER EIGHT – TRIAL BY FIRE |
106 |
The Downfall of Justice |
107 |
The Demagogue as Prosecutor and Hypnotist |
109 |
The Trial as an Instrument of Intimidation |
113 |
The Congressional Investigation |
114 |
The Witness and his Subjective Testimony |
116 |
The Right to be Silent |
118 |
Mental Blackmail |
119 |
The Judge and the Jury |
122 |
Televised Interrogation |
124 |
The Quest for Detachment |
125 |
3
CHAPTER NINE – FEAR AS A TOOL OF TERROR |
126 |
The Fear of Living |
126 |
Our Fantasies about Danger |
129 |
Paradoxical Fear |
130 |
Regression |
131 |
Camouflage and Disguise |
132 |
Explosive Panics |
134 |
The Body Takes Over |
135 |
PART THREE
Unobtrusive Coercion |
137 |
CHAPTER TEN – THE CHILD IS FATHER TO THE MAN |
137 |
How some Totalitarians may Develop |
138 |
The Moulding Nursery |
140 |
The Father cuts the Cord |
145 |
CHAPTER ELEVEN – MENTAL CONTAGION AND MASS DELUSION |
149 |
The Affirmation of my own Errors |
149 |
Stages of Thinking and Delusion |
152 |
The Loss of Verifiable Reality |
154 |
Mass Delusion |
156 |
The Danger of Mental Contagion |
159 |
The Explanation of Delusion |
161 |
The Liberation from Magic Thinking |
162 |
CHAPTER TWELVE – TECHNOLOGY INVADES OUR MINDS |
163 |
The Creeping Coercion by Technology |
165 |
The Paradox of Technology |
169 |
CHAPTER THIRTEEN – INTRUSION BY THE ADMINISTRATIVE MIND |
172 |
The Administrative Mind |
173 |
The Ailments of those in Public Office |
176 |
The Conference of Unconscious Minds |
178 |
The Bureaucratic Mind |
180 |
4
CHAPTER FOURTEEN – THE TURNCOAT IN EACH OF US |
|
THE CONFUSING INFLUENCE OF THE PROBLEM OF |
|
TREASON AND LOYALTY |
184 |
The Involuntary Traitor |
184 |
The Concept of Treason |
187 |
The Traitor who Consciously takes Option for the Other side |
189 |
Our Treacherous Intellect |
192 |
Self-Betrayal |
193 |
The Development of Loyalty |
196 |
In Praise of Nonconformity |
197 |
The Loyalty Compulsion |
198 |
PART FOUR
In Search of Defences |
203 |
CHAPTER FIFTEEN – TRAINING AGAINST MENTAL TORTURE |
|
THE U.S. CODE FOR RESISTING BRAINWASHING |
204 |
Indoctrination Against Indoctrination? |
207 |
CHAPTER SIXTEEN – EDUCATION FOR DISCIPLINE OR |
|
HIGHER MORALE |
209 |
The Role of Education |
209 |
Discipline and Morale |
213 |
Discipline and Brainwashing |
214 |
The Breaking Point and our Capacity for Frustration |
217 |
CHAPTER SEVENTEEN – FROM OLD TO NEW COURAGE |
|
WHO RESISTS LONGER AND WHY? |
219 |
The Myth of Courage |
221 |
The Morale-Boosting Idea |
224 |
The New Courage |
229 |
CHAPTER EIGHTEEN – FREEDOM – OUR MENTAL BACKBONE |
231 |
The Democratizing Action of Psychology |
232 |
The Battle on Two Fronts |
235 |
The Paradox of Freedom |
238 |
The Future Age of Psychology |
240 |
BIBLIOGRAPHY |
241 |
5
PART ONE
THE TECHNIQUES OF INDIVIDUAL SUBMISSION
The first part of this book is devoted to various techniques used to make man a meek conformist. In addition to actual political occurrences, attention is called to some ideas born in the laboratory and to the drug techniques that facilitate brainwashing. The last chapter deals with the subtle psychological mechanisms of mental submission.
6
CHAPTER ONE
YOU TOO WOULD CONFESS
A fantastic thing is happening in our world. Today a man is no longer punished only for the crimes he has in fact committed. Now he may be compelled to confess to crimes that have been conjured up by his judges, who use his confession for political purposes. It is not enough for us to damn as evil those who sit in judgment. We must understand what impels the false admission of guilt; we must take another look at the human mind in all its frailty and vulnerability.
The Enforced Confession
During the Korean War, an officer of the United States Marine Corps, Colonel Frank H. Schwable, was taken prisoner by the Chinese Communists. After months of intense psychological pressure and physical degradation, he signed a well documented "confession" that the United States was carrying on bacteriological warfare against the enemy. The confession named names, cited missions, described meetings and strategy conferences. This was a tremendously valuable propaganda tool for the totalitarians. They cabled the news all over the world: "The United States of America is fighting the peace loving people of China by dropping bombs loaded with disease spreading bacteria, in violation of international law."
After his repatriation, Colonel Schwable issued a sworn statement repudiating his confession, and describing his long months of imprisonment. Later, he was brought before a military court of inquiry. He testified in his own defense before that court: "I was never convinced in my own mind that we in the First Marine Air Wing had used bug warfare. I knew we hadn't, but the rest of it was real to me the conferences, the planes, and how they would go about their missions."
"The words were mine," the Colonel continued, "but the thoughts were theirs. That is the hardest thing I have to explain: how a man can sit down and write something he knows is false, and yet, to sense it, to feel it, to make it seem real."
This is the way Dr. Charles W. Mayo, a leading American physician and government representative, explained brainwashing in an official statement before the United Nations: "...the tortures used...although they include many brutal physical injuries, are not like the medieval torture of the rack and the thumb screw. They are subtler, more prolonged, and intended to be more terrible in their effect. They are calculated to disintegrate the mind of an intelligent victim, to distort his sense of values, to a point where he will not simply cry out 'I did it!' but will become a seemingly willing accomplice to the complete disintegration of his integrity and the production of an elaborate fiction."
The Schwable case is but one example of a defenceless prisoner being compelled to tell a big lie. If we are to survive as free men, we must face up to this problem of politically inspired mental coercion, with all its ramifications.
7
It is more than twenty years (in 1956) since psychologists first began to suspect that the human mind can easily fall prey to dictatorial powers. In 1933, the German Reichstag building was burned to the ground. The Nazis arrested a Dutchman, Marinus Van der Lubbe, and accused him of the crime. Van der Lubbe was known by Dutch psychiatrists to be mentally unstable. He had been a patient in a mental institution in Holland. And his weakness and lack of mental balance became apparent to the world when he appeared before the court. Wherever news of the trial reached, men wondered: "Can that foolish little fellow be a heroic revolutionary, a man who is willing to sacrifice his life to an ideal?"
During the court sessions Van der Lubbe was evasive, dull, and apathetic. Yet the reports of the Dutch psychiatrists described him as a gay, alert, unstable character, a man whose moods changed rapidly, who liked to vagabond around, and who had all kinds of fantasies about changing the world.
On the forty second day of the trial, Van der Lubbe's behaviour changed dramatically. His apathy disappeared. It became apparent that he had been quite aware of everything that had gone on during the previous sessions. He criticized the slow course of the procedure. He demanded punishment either by imprisonment or death. He spoke about his "inner voices." He insisted that he had his moods in check. Then he fell back into apathy. We now recognize these symptoms as a combination of behaviour forms which we can call a confession syndrome. In 1933 this type of behaviour was unknown to psychiatrists. Unfortunately, it is very familiar today and is frequently met in cases of extreme mental coercion.
Van der Lubbe was subsequently convicted and executed. When the trial was over, the world began to realize that he had merely been a scapegoat. The Nazis themselves had burned down the Reichstag building and had staged the crime and the trial so that they could take over Germany. Still later we realized that Van der Lubbe was the victim of a diabolically clever misuse of medical knowledge and psychological technique, through which he had been transformed into a useful, passive, meek automaton, who replied merely yes or no to his interrogators during most of the court sessions. In a few moments he threatened to jump out of his enforced role. Even at that time there were rumours that the man had been drugged into submission, though we never became sure of that.
(NOTE: The psychiatric report about the case of Van der Lubbe is published by Bonhoeffer and Zutt. Though they were unfamiliar with the "menticide syndrome," and not briefed by their political fuehrers, they give a good description about the pathologic, apathetic behaviour, and his tremendous change of moods. They deny the use of drugs.)
Between 1936 and 1938 the world became more conscious of the very real danger of systematized mental coercion in the field of politics. This was the period of the well remembered Moscow purge trials. It was almost impossible to believe that dedicated old Bolsheviks, who had given their lives to a revolutionary movement, had suddenly turned into dastardly traitors. When, one after another, everyone of the accused confessed and beat his breast, the general reaction was that this was a great show of deception, intended only as a propaganda move for the non Communist world.
8
Then it became apparent that a much worse tragedy was being enacted. The men on trial had once been human beings. Now they were being systematically changed into puppets. Their puppeteers called the tune and manipulated their actions. When, from time to time, news came through showing how hard, rigid revolutionaries could be changed into meek, self accusing sheep, all over the world the last remnants of the belief in the free community presumably being built in Soviet Russia began to crumble.
In recent years, the spectacle of confession to uncommitted crimes has become more and more common. The list ranges from Communist through non Communist to anti Communist, and includes men of such different types as the Czech Bolshevik Rudolf Slansky and the Hungarian cardinal, Joseph Mindszenty.
9
Mental Coercion and Enemy Occupation
Those of us who lived in the Nazi occupied countries during the Second World War learned to understand only too well how people could be forced into false confessions, and into betrayals of those they loved. I myself was born in the Netherlands and lived there until the Nazi occupation forced me to flee. In the early days of the occupation, when we heard the first eyewitness descriptions of what happened during Nazi interrogations of captured resistance workers, we were frightened and alarmed.
The first aim of the Gestapo was to force prisoners under torture to betray their friends and to report new victims for further torture. The Brown Shirts demanded names and more names, not bothering to ascertain whether or not they were given falsely under the stress of terror. I remember very clearly one meeting held by a small group of resisters to discuss the growing fear and insecurity. Everybody at that meeting could expect to be mentioned and picked up by the Gestapo at some time. Should we be able to stand the Nazi treatment, or would we also be forced to become informers? This question was being asked by anti Nazis in all the occupied countries.
During the second year of the occupation we realized that it was better not to be in touch with one another. More than two contacts were unsafe. We tried to find medical and psychiatric preventives to harden us against the Nazi torture we expected. As a matter of fact, I myself conducted some experiments to determine whether or not narcotics would harden us against pain. However, the results were paradoxical. Narcotics can create pain insensitivity, but their dulling action at the same time makes people more vulnerable to mental pressure. Even at that time we knew, as did the Nazis themselves, that it was not the direct physical pain that broke people, but the continuous humiliation and mental torture. One of my patients, who was subjected to such an interrogation, managed to remain silent. He refused to answer a single question, and finally the Nazis dismissed him. But he never recovered from this terrifying experience. He hardly spoken even when he returned home. He simply sat bitter, full of indignation and in a few weeks he died. It was not his physical wounds that had killed him; it was the combination of fear and wounded pride.
We held many discussions about ways of strengthening our captured underground workers or preventing them from final self betrayal. Should some of our people be given suicide capsules? That could only be a last resort. Narcotics like morphine give only a temporary anaesthesia and relief; moreover, the enemy would certainly find the capsules and take them away.
We had heard about German attempts to give cocaine and amphetamine to their air pilots for use in combat exhaustion, but neither medicament was reliable. Those drugs might revive the body by making it less sensitive to pain, but at the same time they dulled the mind. If captured members of the underground were to take them, as experiments had shown, their bodies might not feel the effects of physical torture, but their hazy minds might turn them into easier dupes of the Nazis.
10