Добавил:
Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:

!!Экзамен зачет 2023 год / The Law of Obligations

.pdf
Скачиваний:
6
Добавлен:
16.05.2023
Размер:
24.52 Mб
Скачать

xliv

 

 

Table of Contents

 

 

 

 

Page

2.

Actio furti manifest! .....................................................

 

936

 

(a) The discrimination of the manifest thief .............

936

 

(b)

The concept of furtum manifestum ......................

938

 

(c) The quaestio lance et licio.....................................

939

3.

Other remedies available in case of theft ....................

940

4.

Concurrence of actions ................................................

942

III. Furtum in the Ius Commune ..........................................

943

1. The demise of the actio furti .......................................

943

2.

The history of the modern concept of theft................

945

3.

The condictio ex causa furtiva.....................................

947

IV. South African Developments .........................................

948

1. The concept of theft in criminal law...........................

948

2.

The condictio ex causa furtiva.....................................

951

 

 

CHAPTER 29 — LEX AQUILIA I

 

I. Origin and Content of the Lex Aquilia........................

953

1.

The essential data provided in the Digest ...................

953

2.

The problem ot the second chapter.............................

954

3.

Dating the lex Aquilia

..................................................

955

4.

The composition of the lex Aquilia ............................

957

5.

The text of the lex Aquilia ..........................................

959

II. The Assessment of the Sum of Condemnation............

961

1.

Chapter one ..................................................................

 

961

2.

Chapter three................................................................

 

962

 

(a) Chapters one and three compared........................

962

 

(b)

"Erit" or "fuit" ("fuerit")? ...................................

963

 

(c) The meaning of "ea res"......................................

964

 

(d) The original scope of chapter three .....................

965

 

(e)

"Is anything . . .

exempt from doubt?" ..............

966

III. The Nature of the Actio Legis Aquiliae ........................

969

1.

The reipersecutory character of the remedy ...............

969

 

(a)

Chapter one ..........................................................

 

969

 

(b)

Chapter three ........................................................

 

972

2.

The penal character of the remedy..............................

973

IV. The Statutory Definition of the Delict: Harmful

 

Result ..................................................................................

 

 

975

1.

Quadrupedes pecudes...................................................

 

976

2.

Occidere and mortis causam praebere.........................

976

3. The meaning of occidere .............................................

978

4. Actio directa and actio in factum ................................

981

5.

Urere frangere rumpere—corrumpere .......................

983

6.

The limits of the notion of corrumpere......................

986

Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com)

Table of Contents

xlv

V. Some Additional Reflections

Page

 

988

1.

Causation in the Roman law of delict............................

988

 

(a)

"Factual" and "legal" causation ..............................

988

 

(b)

The Roman approach ...............................................

991

 

(c)

Concurrent causation ................................................

992

2.

The actio legis Aquiliae and analogous remedies .........

993

 

(a) Actio directa and actiones in factum .......................

993

 

(b)

Actiones utiles.............................................................

994

 

(c)

Justinian's rationalization ..........................................

996

 

 

CHAPTER 30 — LEX AQUILIA II

 

 

I. The Statutory Definition of the Delict: Iniuria ............

998

1.

Damnum iniuria datum ....................................................

998

 

(a) The notion of "non iure facere" .............................

998

 

(b)

Self-defence.................................................................

999

 

(c)

Necessity .....................................................................

1000

 

(d)

Actions of a magistrate.............................................

1003

 

(c)

Consent .......................................................................

1003

2.

The relationship between iniuria and culpa ..................

1004

 

(a)

The new interpretation: damnum culpa datum. .

1004

 

(b)

"Occidere", "urere frangere rumpere" iniuria.. .

1005

 

(c)

From (typical) dolus to fault at large.....................

1005

 

(d)

Wrongfulness and fault.............................................

1006

3 Aquilian culpa in classical Roman law .........................

1007

4.

"Contributory negligence" in Roman law ....................

1010

 

(a) The Roman all-or-nothing approach .....................

1010

 

(h)

Of javelin-throwers and itinerant barbers .............

1011

 

(c)

Balancing of fault, preponderant negligence or

 

 

 

 

assumption of risk? ...................................................

1012

II. The Protection of a Freeman's Bodily Integrity ...........

1014

1.

Damage to property .........................................................

1014

2.

Liberum corpus nullam recipit aestimationem ............

1015

3.

Injury to sons in power ...................................................

1015

4.

The liber homo bona fide serviens.................................

1016

III. The Usus M odernus Legis Aquiliae .................................

\()\1

1.

Introduction........................................................................

1017

2.

The assessment clauses and litiscrescence ......................

1019

3.

The Jjenal nature of the remedy .....................................

1019

4.

Cumulative liability ..........................................................

1020

5.

Passive intransmissibility..................................................

1020

 

(a)

Canonist doctrine ......................................................

1020

 

(b)

Forum civile ...............................................................

1021

Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com)

xlvi

 

Table of Contents

 

 

 

Page

6.

Purely patrimonial loss.................................................

1022

 

(a)

Roman law and Inst. IV, 3, 16 i.f. .......................

1022

 

(b)

Damnum datum, sed non in corpus....................

1023

7.

The protection of a freeman's life and bodily integrity

1024

8.

Compensation for pain, suffering and disfigurement

1026

9.

Culpa ............................................................................

1027

 

(a)

In general ..............................................................

1027

 

(b)

Culpa in omittendo ..............................................

1029

 

(c)

Concurrence of fault.............................................

1030

IV. Towards the Modern, Generalized Law of Delict . . .

1031

1.

Legal theory and mores hodiernae...............................

1031

2.

The "natural" law of delict..........................................

1032

3.

Fault as the basis of delictual liability ..........................

1033

 

(a)

Thomasius.............................................................

1033

 

(b)

Grotius, Pufendorf and others .............................

1033

 

(c)

Nineteenth-century legal science..........................

1034

4.

Purely patrimonial loss.................................................

1035

 

(a)

The natural lawyers ..............................................

1035

 

(b)

Germany (19th century) .......................................

1036

 

(c)

England .................................................................

1038

 

(d)

Germany (20th century) .......................................

1040

 

(e)

Austria and South Africa......................................

1042

5.

Liability for omissions .................................................

1043

 

(a)

The priest, the levite and the Good Samaritan ..

1043

 

(b)

Modern approach..................................................

1045

 

(c)

" Verkehrssicherungspflichten" ..................................

1046

6.

Contributory negligence ..............................................

1047

 

(a)

Developments in continental Europe ..................

1047

 

(b)

South African law.................................................

1048

 

 

CHAPTER 31 — АСТЮ INIURIARUM

 

I. The Early History of Iniuria ..........................................

1050

1.

Iniuria in the XII Tables...............................................

1050

2. The rise of the actio iniuriarum...................................

1052

II. Classical Foundations of the Actio Iniuriarum ............

1053

1. The different forms of iniuria......................................

1053

 

(a)

Convicium ............................................................

1053

 

(b)

De adtemptata pudicitia........................................

1054

 

(c)

Ne quid infamandi causa fiat ...............................

1056

 

(d)

Servum alienum verberare ...................................

1058

 

(e)

Residual cases........................................................

1058

Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com)

Table of Contents

 

 

xlvii

2. The essential elements of iniuria

Page

1059

 

(a)

Contumelia; contra bonos mores ........................

1059

 

(b)

The problem of the animus iniuriandi ................

1059

 

(c)

Characteristics of the actio iniuriarum.................

1061

III. The Usus Modernus of the Actio Iniuriarum .............

1062

1.

"Mine honour is my life . . .

".....................................

1062

2.

The definition of iniuria ..............................................

 

1064

3.

Of hunchbacks,

cuckolds,

clergymen and flouncy

 

skirts .............................................................................

 

 

1065

4.

Animus iniuriandi........................................................

 

1067

 

(a) Presumption of animus iniuriandi .......................

1067

 

(b)

Rebuttal of the presumption ................................

1068

5.

Remedies ......................................................................

 

 

1070

 

(a)

Actio iniuriarum aestimatoria ..............................

1070

 

(b)

Criminal proceedings ...........................................

 

1071

 

(c)

Amende honorable ...............................................

 

1072

 

(d)

The relation

between

amende honorable

and

 

 

amende profitable.................................................

 

1073

IV. Defamation in English Law ...........................................

 

1074

1.

Technicalities beyond belief........................................

 

1074

2.

Libel and slander ..........................................................

 

 

1074

3.

Common elements ......................................................

 

1076

4.

"Animus iniuriandi" and Artemus Jones ....................

1077

V. South African Usus Modernus of the Actio

 

Iniuriarum ..........................................................................

 

 

1078

1.

The battle about animus iniuriandi...............................

1078

2.

Compromise solutions..................................................

 

1080

3.

A hybrid law of defamation........................................

 

1080

4.

The concept of iniuria...................................................

 

1081

5.

Corpus, dignitas and fama ...........................................

 

1083

VI. The Fate of the Actio Iniuriarum in Germany .............

1085

1.

Usus modernus and natural law ..................................

1085

2.

De iniquitate et iniustitia actionum iniuriarum ............

1087

3.

The shift from private law to criminal law .................

1088

4.

Criticism of the actio ad palinodiam ...........................

1090

5.

The decline of the actio iniuriarum aestimatoria .........

1090

6.

The renaissance of the actio iniuriarum ......................

1092

 

 

CHAPTER 32 — STRICT LIABILITY

 

I. Liability for Damage done by Animals.........................

1095

1.

A special compartment.................................................

 

1095

Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com)

xlviii

 

Table of Contents

 

2.

 

 

Page

 

The actio de pauperic in Roman law ..............................

1096

 

 

(a)

The meaning of pauperics.........................................

1096

 

 

(b)

The principle of noxality .........................................

1099

 

 

(c)

Range of application .................................................

1101

 

 

(d)

The "contra naturam " test.......................................

1102

 

3.

The edictum de feris in Roman law ................................

1104

 

 

(a)

W ild animals in Rome ..............................................

1104

 

 

(b) The intervention of the praetor ...............................

1106

 

4.

The actio de pastu in Roman law ...................................

1107

 

5.

The actio dc pastu in South African law ......................

1108

 

6.

The edictum de feris in South African law ...................

1109

 

7.

The actio de pauperie in South African law .................

1110

 

 

(a) The nature of the remedy ........................................

1110

 

 

(b)

Range of animals .......................................................

1113

 

 

(c)

Contra HIS naturale ....................................................

1113

 

 

(d)

Contra naturam sui generis .....................................

1114

 

 

(e)

The "reasonable cow" test.......................................

1115

 

8.

Liability for damage done by animals in modern

 

 

 

German law ........................................................................

1116

II.

Vicarious Liability..................................................................

1118

 

1. The principle of noxality .................................................

1118

 

 

(a)

Roman law .................................................................

1118

 

 

(b)

"[Njoxalium actionum nullus est usus" .................

1118

 

2.

Liability for others in Rom an law (apart from noxal

 

 

 

liability)................................................................................

1120

 

 

(a)

W ithin a contractual context ...................................

1120

 

 

(b)

Custodia ......................................................................

1121

 

 

(c)

Delictual and quasi-delictual remedies...................

1121

 

3.

Vicarious liability in South African law ........................

1123

 

4.

The position in modern French and German law . . . .

1124

III. Quasi-delictual Liability ......................................................

1126

 

1.

The fate of the Roman quasi-delicts ...............................

1126

 

2.

Delictual and quasi-delictual liability .............................

1128

IV. New Instances of No-fault Liability ...............................

1130

 

1.

Legislation in the 19th century ........................................

ИЗО

 

2.

Strict liability in disguise ..................................................

1132

 

3.

20th-century ad hoc legislation .......................................

1133

V.

Strict Liability in English Law ...........................................

1135

 

1.

Vicarious liability ..............................................................

1135

 

2. Liability for damage done by animals............................

1136

 

3.

Rylands v. Fletcher..............................................................

1138

 

4. The quest for strict liability in modern law ..................

1140

VI. Origin and Application of Art. 1384 Code Civil..........

1141

Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com)

Table of Contents

xlix

 

 

 

Page

Index of Main Sources

 

1.

Roman Legal Sources...................................................

1143

 

(a)

Justinianic ..............................................................

1143

 

(b)

Non-Justinianic ......................................................

1179

2.

Ancient Non-Legal Sources .........................................

1184

3.

Corpus Juris Canonici ..................................................

1187

4.

Continental Codifications ............................................

1187

 

(a)

Constitutio Criminalis Carolina...........................

1187

 

(b)

Preussisches Allgemeines Landrecht ....................

1188

 

(c)

Code civil .............................................................

1189

 

(d)

Allgemeines Burgerliches Gesetzbuch ..................

1190

 

(e)

Burgerliches Gesetzbuch.......................................

1191

5.

Table of Cases ..............................................................

1196

 

(a) United Kingdom, United States and Common

 

 

 

wealth ...................................................................

1196

 

(b)

South Africa..........................................................

1199

 

(c)

Germany................................................................

1205

Subject Index

.................................................................................

1207

Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com)

List of abbreviations

Abbreviation

Full citation, name or spelling

 

 

Place

A

Appellate Division

 

 

SA

A.D.

anno Domini

 

 

6

ABGB

Allgemeines Biirgerliches Gesctzbuch

 

AC

Law Reports, Appeal cases

 

 

Eng

AD

Appellate Division Reports

 

 

SA

Ad& El

Adolphus & Ellis's Reports,

King's

Bench and

 

ADHO-RIDA

Queen's Bench

 

 

Eng

Archives d'histoire dn droit oriental

(1952-53

В

Afr.

combined with RIDA)

 

 

Africanus

 

 

 

 

AG

Amtsgcricht

 

 

Ger

AGBG

Gesetz zur Regelung des Rcchts der Allgemeinen

 

AHDE

Geschaftsbedingungen

 

 

Ger

Anuario de historia del derecho espanol

 

E

AJ

Acting Judge

 

 

 

AJA

Acting judge of Appeal

 

 

 

Alex. Scv.

Alexander Sevcrus

 

 

 

Aleyn

Aleyn's Reports, King's Bench

 

Eng

Alf.

A1 fen us

 

 

 

 

All ER

All England Law Reports

 

 

Eng

Annali Bart

Annali della Facolta di Giurisprudenza dell' Univer-

 

 

sita di Bari

 

 

1

Annali Catania

Annali del Setninario Guiridico dell' Universita di

 

 

Catania

 

 

 

I

Aimali Palermo

Annali del

Seminario Giuridico

dell' Universita di

 

 

Palermo

 

 

 

I

anon.

anonymous

 

 

 

ANRW

Ли/if if (j

und Niedergang der

rb'mischen Welt,

 

 

Geschichte und Kultur Roms im Spiegel der

 

 

neueren Forsclutng (ed. H. Temporini, W. Haase,

 

 

pp. 1972 sqq.)

 

 

Ger

Ant.

Antoninus

 

 

 

 

App DC

Appeal Cases, District of Columbia

 

USA

Arcad.

Arcadius

 

 

 

 

arg.

argument

 

 

 

 

art., Art.

article

 

 

 

 

am., Artt.

articles

 

 

 

 

A*AS

Aulus Agerius

 

 

 

Aug.

Augustus

 

 

 

 

Aus

Australia

 

 

 

 

Australian LJ

Australian Law Journal

 

 

Aus

В

Belgium

 

 

 

 

В & Aid

Barncwall and Aiderson's Reports, King's Bench

Eng

В & S

Best & Smith's Reports, Queen's Bench

Eng

B.C.

before Christ

 

 

 

ВAGE

Entscheidungen des Bundesarbeitsgerichts

Ger

BGB

Biirgerliches Gesetzbuch

 

 

Ger

BGB1

Bundesgesctzbiatt

 

 

Ger

Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com)

Hi

List of abbreviations

Abbreviation

h'uil citation, name or spelling

Placeororigin

BGH

Bun desgericht shot"

Ger

BGHZ

Entscheidungcn des Bundesgerichtshofs in

 

BIDR

Zivilsachen

Ger

Bitlletitw dell'Istituto di diritto romano

I

Bing

Bingham's Reports, Common Fleas

Eng

Bins? (NC)

Bingham's New Cases, Common Picas

Eng

Black W

William Blackstone's Reports. King's Bench and

 

Boston University LR

Common Pleas

Eng

Boston University Law Review

USA

Bpk.

Beperk (= Limited)

 

Buch

Buchanan's Reports

SA

Buch AC

Buchanan's Appeal Cases, Cape Appeal Court

SA

Burr

Burrow's Reports, King's Bench

Eng

Butterworth's South

Butterworth's South African Law Review

 

African LR

SA

BVerfC.

Bundesverfassungsgcricht

Ger

BVerfGE

Entscheidungcn des Bundesverfassungsgcrichts

Or

BW

Burgerlijk Wctboek

 

с

Cape Provincial Division

SA

 

с.

Codex lustinianus

 

с.

canon (Corpus Juris Canonici)

 

CA

Court of Appeal

EnB

California LR

California Law Review

USA

Call.

Calli stratus

 

Cambridge L]

Cambridge LawJournal

Eng

Camp

Campbolls's Reports Nisi prius

Eng

Can

Canada

 

Can.

Canon (Codex Juris Cononici)

 

Cap., cap.

Caput

 

Carac.

Caracalla

 

Cases T. Talbot

Cases in Equity temp. Talbot

Eng

Cass.

Cassius

 

CB

Chief Baron; Common Bench Reports

Eng

CB (NS)

Common Bench Reports (New Series)

Eng

c.c.

code civil

Fr

CCC

Constitutio Criminalis Carolina

 

Ccls.

Cclsus

 

cf.

conier

 

Ch

Law Reports. Chancery Division

E»K

СИ

Switzerland

 

Ch. reun.

Cour de Cassation, Chambres reunies

Fr

chap.

chapter

 

ChD

Chancery Division; Law Reports Chancery Divi-

 

 

sion

Eng

Ciha

The Comparative and International Law Journal of

 

cj

Southern Africa

SA

Chief Justice

 

CLR

Commonwealth Law Reports

Aus

Cmnd.

Command Papers, 5th series

Eng

Co Rep

Coke's Reports

Eng

Co.

Company

 

Cod.

Codex

 

Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com)

List of abbreviations

 

 

liii

Abbreviation

Full citation, name or spelling

 

Placeororigin

 

col.

column

 

 

 

 

Coll.

Mosaicarum et Romanarum legum collatio

 

 

Columbia LR

Columbia Law Review

 

USA

Concl.

Conclusio

 

 

 

Cons.

Consilium

 

 

 

Const.

Constantinus; Constitutio

 

 

 

Cowp

Cowpcr's Reports, King's Bench

 

Eng

Cox

Cox's Equity Cases

 

Eng

CP

Law Reports, Common Pleas

 

Eng

CPD

Reports of the Cape Provincial Division

SA

Cro Jac

Croke's Reports temp. James!., King's Bench and

 

 

 

Common Pleas

 

Eng

CT

Codex Theodosianus

 

 

 

D

Dunlop,

Court of Session Cases

(Scotland);

 

 

 

Durban and Coastal Local Division (South

 

 

 

Africa)

 

 

 

D & R

Dowling & Rylands's Reports, King's Bench

Eng

IX

Digesta

 

 

 

 

DC Cir

District of Columbia Court of Appeal Cases

USA

Dec-. Decis.

Decisio

 

 

 

 

Diocl.

Diocletianus

 

 

 

Disp.

Disputatio

 

 

 

Dist.

Distinctio

 

 

 

Dougl

Douglas' Reports, King's Bench

 

Eng

Dr & Sm

Drewry and Smale's Reports, Chancery

Eng

E

Spain

 

 

 

 

E I

First draft of the German Civil Code (BGH)

Ger

<-■■£-

tor example

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

East

East's Reports, King's Bench

 

Eng

ED

Fjuidopedia del diritto

 

1

 

ed., eds.

edition, editor; editions, editors

 

 

 

EDC

Reports of the Eastern Districts Court ot the Cape

 

 

 

of Good Hope

 

SA

EDL

Reports of the Eastern Districts Local Division

SA

Ednis.

Eiendoms (— Proprietary)

 

 

 

Edw

Edward

 

 

Eng

EheG.

Ehegesetz

 

Ger

Eins.

Eiendoms (— Proprietary)

 

 

 

El & Bl

Ellis and Blackburn's Reports, Queen's Bench

Eng

Eng

England

 

 

 

 

Eq

Equity Reports; Equity Cases

 

Eng

esp.

especially

 

 

 

Ex D

Law Reports. Exchequer Division

 

Eng

Exch

Exchequer; Law Reports Exchequer

 

Eng

Exerc.

Exercitatio

 

 

 

F

Federal Reporter

 

USA

F2d

Federal Reporter. 2nd Series

 

USA

FC

Federal Supreme Court of Southern

 

 

 

FIRA, vol. Ill

Rhodesia

 

ZB

Уantes

luris Romani Attteiustiniatii.

Pars tertia,

 

 

 

Negotia (cd. V. Arangio-Ruiz), 2nd ed., 1972

 

 

Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com)

liv

 

List of abbreviations

 

Full citation, name or spelling

Place or origin

 

Flor.

Florcntinus

 

 

 

Foord

Foord's Reports, Cape Supreme Court

SA

Fr

France

 

 

 

Fr. vat.

Fragmenta vaticana

 

 

Gai.

Gaius

 

 

 

Gall.

Gallienus

 

 

 

Ger

Germany

 

 

 

GG

Grundgesctz

 

Ger

gl-

glossa

 

 

 

Gord.

Gordianus

 

 

 

GriinhZ

Zeitschrift fur das Privatund OffentHche Recht der

 

 

 

Gegenwart

 

Ger

H

Greece

 

 

 

H& С

Hurlstone & Coltman's Reports, Exchequer

Eng

H Bl

Henry Blackstone's Reports, Common

 

 

 

Fleas

 

Eng

Harvard LR

Harvard Law Review

USA

Hastings International

 

 

 

and Comparative

 

USA

LR

Hastings International and Comparative Law Review

HCG

Reports of the High Court of Griqualand

SA

Негтоц.

Hermogeniaims

 

 

 

HL

House of Lords

 

UK

HLC

Clark's Reports, House of Lords

Eng

HRG

Handworterbuch zur deutschen

 

 

 

Rechtsgeschichte (see bibliography)

 

 

I Itp.

Italy

 

 

 

Index Interpolationum

 

 

 

i.e.

id est

 

 

 

i.f.

in fine

 

 

 

lav.

Iavolerms

 

 

 

ibia.

ibidem

 

 

 

Imp.

Imperator

 

 

 

Impp.

Imperatores

 

 

 

Index

Index, Quaderni camerti di studi romanistici

 

I

Just.

Jnstitutiones Justiniani

 

 

 

itp.

interpolated

 

 

 

Iul.

Iulianus

 

 

 

Jura

Rivista internazionale di diritto romano e antico

 

I

J

Judge of Appeal

 

 

 

JA

 

 

 

Jhjb

Jherings Jahrbiklier fir die Dogmatik des Inirgerlichen

 

 

JJP

Rechts

Ger

 

 

The Journal of Juristic Papyroiogy

 

P

JP

Judge President

 

 

 

JRS

Journal of Roman Studies Eng

 

 

Juridical Review The Juridical Review

Sc

 

 

Just.

Justinian

 

 

 

KB

King's Bench; Law Reports King's Bench

 

 

Division

Eng

 

 

 

 

 

KG

Kammergericht

Ger

 

 

 

 

 

 

Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com)

Соседние файлы в папке !!Экзамен зачет 2023 год